When an employer calls you for a reference, it can feel oddly high-stakes, especially if you care about the person and you also want to be fair and truthful. I have sat on both sides of this conversation, first in university admissions and later in corporate recruiting, including hiring for nursing roles and remote tech positions. A solid reference call is rarely about saying the “perfect” thing. It is about confirming the basics, giving specific examples, and staying within what you actually know.
This guide is written for you, the person being asked to give the reference, not the job seeker. You will find: what employers usually ask, what to confirm with the candidate before you say a word, and exactly how to respond, including what to do if you cannot offer a strong reference.

Before you answer: what to confirm with the candidate
If the candidate gave your name and you were expecting the call, great. If you were not expecting it, you can still handle it professionally. Your first step is to make sure you have the right context so your reference is accurate and helpful.
One quick policy check: Some organizations require references to go through HR or limit managers and employees to verifying title and dates only. Before you share anything beyond basic employment verification, follow your workplace policy.
Quick checklist to text or call the candidate about
- What role are you applying for? (Title, employer, team if known.)
- What is the job emphasizing? (Leadership, customer service, clinical judgment, speed, collaboration, remote work habits, etc.)
- What should I highlight? Ask for 2 to 3 accomplishments they want you to reinforce.
- What dates and title should I use? Confirm start and end dates, job title(s), reporting line, and whether they were full-time, part-time, PRN, contract, or intern.
- Anything sensitive I should be aware of? For example, name change, relocation timing, or a gap they will explain in interviews.
- Can I be candid? A good candidate will say yes. Your honesty matters.
- What name and pronouns should I use? It is a small detail that prevents awkwardness and shows respect.
If you are a coworker (not a manager), clarify how you worked together so you can answer confidently: “peer on the same shift,” “trained together,” “worked cross-functionally,” “I was the project lead,” etc.
Tip from recruiting: If you have not worked with them in a while, ask for their current resume or LinkedIn profile so you can refresh your memory. You are not looking for a script. You are looking for accuracy.
When the employer calls: a simple structure that works every time
You do not need to ramble to be helpful. Most strong reference calls follow a clean, predictable flow. Here is the structure I recommend.
Practical tip: Take brief notes during the call. It helps you stay specific, and it is useful if the employer follows up later.
1) Confirm who you are and your relationship
Start with your name, role, and how you know the candidate. Be specific about the timeframe and context.
“Hi, this is Maya Caldwell. I supervised Jordan Lee when they worked as a patient care technician on our med-surg unit from June 2022 to August 2024.”
2) Confirm the basics you can ethically confirm
Employers typically want to confirm employment details and performance context. If you are unsure, say so rather than guessing. If your workplace policy limits what you can share, say that up front and stop where the policy requires you to stop.
“I can confirm Jordan’s position and dates of employment, and I am happy to share my direct observations about their work within what I am allowed to discuss.”
3) Give 2 to 4 specific examples
Specific beats glowing. Choose examples that match the role. Think: measurable outcomes, situations you witnessed, and behaviors that mattered.
“One example that stands out: during high census periods, Jordan consistently kept turnaround tight without sacrificing patient comfort. They also coached two new hires on our rounding process, which reduced call-light volume on that wing.”
4) Answer questions directly, then pause
Reference calls are often fast. Let the employer guide the questions. After answering, stop talking and allow the next question.
5) End by confirming availability
Close professionally, and offer a brief follow-up channel if needed.
“That covers what I observed directly. If you have any follow-up questions, I am happy to answer them now or by email.”

What employers usually ask in a reference call
Most reference checks are designed to verify what the candidate has already shared and to reduce hiring risk. The exact questions vary by industry, but these are very common.
Relationship and verification
- How do you know the candidate?
- What were their job title and responsibilities?
- What were their dates of employment?
- Did you directly supervise them? If not, how closely did you work together?
Performance and strengths
- What were their top strengths?
- How would you describe their work quality?
- How do they handle feedback and coaching?
- How do they perform under pressure?
- How do they communicate with colleagues or clients?
Reliability and professionalism
- How was their attendance and punctuality?
- How did they manage deadlines or shift demands?
- Were there any policy issues you observed?
Team fit and leadership
- How do they collaborate?
- How do they handle conflict?
- Did they mentor others or lead informally?
The big closing question
- Would you rehire them?
That last one matters because it forces a clear, practical answer. If your answer is “yes,” say it plainly. If it is “no” or “not in this kind of role,” keep reading for how to decline or how to be honest without being reckless.
What to say: ready-to-use scripts for common moments
Use these as starting points. Adjust to your voice and your relationship to the candidate.
Script: when you can confidently recommend them
“Yes, I would recommend them. I found them dependable, steady under pressure, and thoughtful with both teammates and customers. In particular, I saw them take ownership of problems instead of passing them along. If you are hiring for a role that needs consistency and follow-through, they are a strong choice.”
Script: when you were a coworker, not a manager
“I was not their direct supervisor, but I worked alongside them on the same team for about 18 months. From what I observed day-to-day, they were prepared, respectful, and they communicated clearly during handoffs. I can speak to how they operated as a peer and teammate.”
Script: when you cannot answer a question
“I did not directly observe that, so I do not want to speculate. What I can speak to is what I saw in our work together, which was…”
Script: when asked about a weakness
“One growth area I saw early on was confidence when presenting to larger groups. The positive is they improved quickly. They asked for feedback, practiced, and within a few months they were leading portions of our team updates.”
Script: when asked “Would you rehire them?”
“Yes, I would rehire them. They were reliable, they took feedback well, and I trusted them with high-priority work.”
Script: when someone asks for “off-the-record” comments
“I am not comfortable speaking off the record. I can share what I directly observed in a job-related way, and I will keep it factual.”
Script: when asked about personal, medical, or protected topics
“I cannot speak to personal or medical information. What I can speak to is their job performance and what I directly observed at work.”
How to decline a reference call if you cannot be positive
This is the part many people dread. In most situations, if you cannot provide a fair, job-relevant reference based on direct experience, the most ethical move is to decline rather than offer speculation, frustration, or “faint praise.”
There are exceptions. In regulated roles, safeguarding contexts, security clearances, or situations where you have a legal or policy obligation to disclose material concerns, you should follow your organization’s rules and any applicable legal guidance.
Ideally, you communicate this to the candidate before an employer ever calls. I have coached many people through this, including military veterans transitioning to civilian roles, and it is always kinder to be direct early than vague later.
Option A: Decline to the employer
“Thank you for reaching out. I am not the best person to provide a useful reference for this role, so I am going to decline. I appreciate your understanding.”
Option B: Decline because you cannot be specific
This is appropriate if you did not work closely enough, it has been many years, or you do not have direct observations.
“I worked with them, but not closely enough to provide the kind of detailed reference that would be fair or useful to you. I recommend contacting someone who directly supervised their day-to-day work.”
Option C: Ask for time
“I want to be thoughtful and accurate. Can I call you back later today after I review my notes on our time working together?”
What to say to the candidate
If you cannot be positive, do not ghost them. Be respectful and brief.
“I want to be transparent. I do not feel I can provide the strong reference you deserve for this search, so it is better if you use someone else. I hope you understand, and I am wishing you the best with the process.”
Important: You do not owe details. You also should not surprise them with a negative reference after agreeing to be one.
How to be honest without oversharing or creating legal risk
You are not expected to deliver a courtroom-style statement. The goal is an accurate picture based on your direct experience. A few guardrails help you stay professional.
- Stick to what you observed. Say “I observed” and “In my experience,” not “Everyone says.”
- Avoid diagnosing or labeling. Skip speculation about health, mental health, substance use, or protected characteristics.
- Use job-related language. Focus on reliability, communication, accuracy, teamwork, and policy compliance.
- Do not share confidential information. That includes patient details, proprietary business data, internal investigations, or HR specifics.
- If asked about termination or discipline: If you do not know, say so. If you do know but it is confidential, you can say you are not able to discuss internal HR matters.
Many employers also have strict reference policies, especially in healthcare and large corporations. If your organization only allows confirmation of title and dates, stop there.
“Company policy limits what I can share. I can confirm their title and dates of employment.”
Make your reference stronger with a few details
If you want to be genuinely helpful, aim for details that predict success in the new role. Here are examples that tend to land well with hiring teams.
Details employers like
- Scope: “Handled 40 to 60 calls a day,” “Supported a 28-bed unit,” “Managed a queue of 15 open tickets.”
- Quality: “Low error rate,” “Consistently strong documentation,” “Trusted to train new hires.”
- Judgment: “Escalated appropriately,” “Stayed calm during emergencies,” “Knew when to ask for help.”
- Collaboration: “Strong handoffs,” “Resolved conflict quickly,” “Partnered well with cross-functional teams.”
- Remote readiness (if relevant): “Communicated proactively,” “Documented work clearly,” “Stayed accountable without needing reminders.”

If you leave a voicemail or get an email request
Sometimes you will miss the call, or the employer will email asking for a time.
Voicemail callback script
“Hi, this is Maya Caldwell. I am returning your call regarding a reference check for Jordan Lee. You can reach me at 415-555-0139. I am available today between 11:30 a.m. and 1:00 p.m. Pacific, or after 4:30 p.m. Pacific.”
Email reply script
Hello Priya Singh,
Thanks for reaching out. I am happy to provide a reference for Jordan Lee. I am available for a brief call on Tuesday between 10:00 a.m. and 12:00 p.m. Pacific, or Wednesday between 2:00 p.m. and 4:00 p.m. Pacific. If another time works better, feel free to suggest a window.
Best regards,
Maya Caldwell
Keep it neutral and scheduling-focused. Save the content for the call.
FAQ
How long do reference calls usually take?
Many are 5 to 15 minutes. For clinical or leadership roles, it can run longer, especially if the hiring manager is calling rather than HR.
Should I ask the employer what questions they will ask?
You can. It is reasonable to say, “What areas would you like me to focus on?” Many employers will tell you: teamwork, reliability, leadership, or role-specific skills.
What if I only have a mixed reference to give?
If you can still recommend the person overall, focus on balanced, job-related feedback and provide context. If you cannot recommend them, decline. “Faint praise” often reads as a warning.
Can I refuse to be a reference even if I agreed earlier?
Yes. If new information changes your comfort level, it is better to step back than to deliver a negative or uncertain reference. Tell the candidate as soon as possible.
Do I need permission from the candidate to speak?
In practice, candidates usually give your name as permission. Still, it is smart to confirm you are comfortable and informed before you talk. If you suspect they listed you without asking, pause and verify with the candidate first.
What if my employer requires HR to handle references?
Follow that policy. You can direct the caller to HR for verification, and if you are not authorized to share more, keep it to what you are allowed to confirm.
A quick prep list
- Confirm your relationship, title, and dates.
- Review the candidate’s resume or LinkedIn for accuracy.
- Pick 2 to 3 specific examples that match the role.
- Decide your clear answer to: “Would you rehire them?”
- Know your boundaries: what you observed, what you cannot share, and what you will decline.
If you show up with accuracy, specifics, and a calm tone, you are already doing this well. Your job is not to sell someone with hype. Your job is to help an employer understand what it is actually like to work with them, and to do it with professionalism and care.